CJI withdraws cases from Justice Amanullah's bench over jurisdiction concerns

By News Desk··~1 min read

Chief Justice Surya Kant withdrew two cases from the bench of Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah after determining it had inappropriately created PIL (public interest litigation) jurisdiction by converting individual disputes into pan-India exercises. The CJI, backed by the four most senior Supreme Court judges, said such expansions violated case-distribution discipline that falls under the Chief Justice's authority.

One case had begun as a dispute over illegal building construction in Tamil Nadu but was broadened to examine construction violations across all state and union territory municipal corporations. An earlier order directing removal of stray animals nationwide had sparked controversy, with a petitioner arguing it risked affecting cows, which have constitutional protection under Indian law. The CJI plans a general survey of other benches to identify similarly expanded cases.

Share
CJI withdraws cases from Justice Amanullah's bench over jurisdiction concerns · The People TV