Goans Abroad, Migrants at Home: It's Time to Drop the Hypocrisy

Goa's own workers went to the Gulf and the UK for a better life. The migrants who filled the gap they left deserve the same respect.

By A Goa-based political observer (name withheld on request)··~2 min read
Goa's migration story cuts both ways. As Goans seek better opportunities overseas, migrant workers from other parts of India contribute to the state's economy. Blaming an entire community for social problems is hypocrisy, not a solution.
Goa's migration story cuts both ways. As Goans seek better opportunities overseas, migrant workers from other parts of India contribute to the state's economy. Blaming an entire community for social problems is hypocrisy, not a solution.

Karl Marx argued that the history of every society so far has been the history of class struggle. In his reading, society is divided into the bourgeoisie, who own the means of production, and the proletariat, who sell their labour, with a middle class of small traders, professionals and salaried workers sandwiched between them like the filling in a hamburger.

Apply that lens to Goa. Over the decades, a large share of Goa's working people have left for the Persian Gulf, the UK and beyond in search of better wages and a better life. There is nothing wrong in that. Everyone wants to build a better future for themselves and their families.

Their departure left a gap in Goa's workforce, and that gap was filled by economic migrants from Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Jharkhand, as well as from neighbouring Maharashtra and Karnataka.

Over time their numbers grew, and so did Goa's working-class settlements, many of them home to migrant families, from Lala ki Basti in Thivim and Kargil Nagar in Curtorim to Moti Dongor in Margao, Khareband near Benaulim and Indira Nagar in Chimbel.

Wherever poverty and overcrowding meet, some crime follows. No society under the sun has escaped this; it is part and parcel of how societies everywhere work.

To blame migrants as a group for it is not only foolish, but shows an ignorance of how a society functions.

How would overseas Goans feel if they were treated with suspicion in their adopted countries, or refused permission to hold Goan Overseas Association meetings or World Goa Day celebrations in the US, the UK or anywhere else? Would they not feel discriminated against and pushed to the margins? What, then, justifies the way some in Goa treat migrants at home?

Shun this hypocrisy. It has never done anyone any good.

Overseas Goans will not be sent back from their adopted countries, and nobody can chase away the migrants who have made Goa their home.

Wake up and smell the coffee. Live and let live.

Share
Goans Abroad, Migrants at Home: It's Time to Drop the Hypocrisy | Opinion · The People TV